| |
The Speaker’s Task Force on Medical Malpractice on Thursday
of this week concluded its deliberations and is
prepared to forward recommendations to the Speaker
and Legislature regarding the reestablishment of
legislatively adopted caps on noneconomic damages
in medical malpractice cases in response to a recent
Supreme Court decision declaring the current caps
to be unconstitutional. (See article below.) This
helps to set the stage for a fall floor period which
is expected to deal with several civil justice issues
in order to address what many believe to be the
number one economic development issue facing the
state - that being the severe damage to Wisconsin’s
“litigation atmosphere.”
Other items pending before, or expected to be introduced soon,
include measures to address two other recent court
cases dealing with punitive damages and employer/seller
liability, as well other product liability changes
and standards for expert opinion evidence.
| In this Issue |
 |
| Malpractice Task Force Provides Recommendations
Supreme Court will hear Eminent Domain Case
Governor Doyle Accepts Report on Wisconsin’s Emergency
Preparedness Plans
New Microgrant Program Spurs Entrepreneur and Inventor Club
Committee Passes Health
Bills
Bill to License Midwives Introduced
Breastfeeding Protection Proposed by Lawmaker
Burke Guilty Plea
Sen. Stepp Won’t Run for Reelection/McReynolds Announces
Candidacy
Poll Shows Governor’s Race Close
Harriet Miers Next Supreme Court Nominee
Restaurants Donate to Red Cross |
| Policy Developments |
 |
| Malpractice Task Force Provides Recommendations
At its final meeting on Oct. 6, the
Assembly Medical Malpractice Task Force
finalized its recommendations for possible
legislative action. While stating that any
legislation should address the Supreme Court’s
recent decision, and should clarify and
reinforce their finding and objectives for
a cap on noneconomic damages, the Task Force
recommended three alternative proposals.
-
Establish a two-tiered system under which injured minors
have a higher cap than injured adults.
-
Establish a cap on noneconomic damages as the greater of
either a base-level cap, or a set amount
times each year of life expectancy of
the injured patient. The life expectancy
factor would be based solely on the
age of the injured patient at the time
of the act of malpractice, not on the
specific health condition either before
or after the malpractice.
-
Cap noneconomic damages at a specific dollar amount.
The Task Force did not recommend dollar mounts for the above
proposals, but recommends methods for determining
an appropriate cap, including considering
what other states use as a cap on noneconomic
damages; actuarial data and studies presented
to the Legislature; the amounts of noneconomic
damage awards in medical malpractice cases
in Wisconsin; and, testimony, data and other
information presented to the Task Force.
Supreme Court will hear Eminent Domain Case
The Wisconsin Supreme Court will hear
a case which involves the eminent domain
acquisition of a home for an airport expansion
project in Milwaukee. The Supreme Court
will clarify what evidence is permitted
in eminent domain cases where property owners
challenge the government’s payment
for their property.
Eminent domain issues have had particular interest since a
recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling heightened
awareness of potential takings of individual
dwellings for purposes of third party development
or redevelopment. AB 657,
currently in the Senate, prohibits the condemnation
of property that is not blighted if the
condemnor intends to convey or lease the
acquired property to a third party private
entity.
Governor Doyle Accepts Report on Wisconsin’s Emergency
Preparedness Plans
On Friday October 7, Governor
Jim Doyle accepted a report from
Major General Al Wilkening, Adjutant General
of Wisconsin and Wisconsin’s Homeland
Security Advisor, evaluating Wisconsin’s
Emergency Preparedness plans and recommending
specific action the state will take to avoid
mistakes made in the response to Hurricane
Katrina. The Governor was joined by the
Red
Cross at the press conference.
-
Mass Evacuation Plans Must be Developed: At the state
level, six key state agencies, in cooperation
with the Red Cross, are responsible
for specific tasks in support of county
and local evacuation and shelter planning.
A key finding of this report is that
while all plans can accommodate small
to medium evacuation and shelter efforts,
they have not planned for a large scale
catastrophe.
-
Special Needs Populations must be Identified Early:
Hurricane Katrina showed the need for
government and private health care providers
to keep track of elderly and disabled
residents and have detailed evacuation
plans for them in place. This review
found that while most Wisconsin counties
and municipalities do maintain lists
of nursing homes and other specialized
care facilities in their plans, there
may be individuals, groups, and facilities
that have not been identified.
-
Evacuation and Emergency Plans are Required for Nursing
Homes, Hospitals and Related Facilities:
Wisconsin law requires nursing homes,
hospitals and related facilities to
have all-hazards emergency response
plans that are exercised on a local
and regional basis annually.
-
Local, State and Federal Responses must be Effectively
Coordinated and Competently Led:
In December, 2004, Governor Doyle issued
Executive Order #81, designating the
National Incident Management System
(NIMS) as the basis for incident management
in the state of Wisconsin, which provides
a single standardized system of emergency
response. The state will encourage local
and tribal governments to adopt NIMS,
providing consistency across levels
of government in an emergency situation.
New Microgrant Program Spurs Entrepreneur and Inventor Club
Economic development corporations, chambers
of commerce and other organizations interested
in creating an Inventor and Entrepreneur
(I&E) Club in their area may now apply
online for a microgrant from the Wisconsin
Entrepreneurs' Network (WEN).
The program is funded by WEN and the Wisconsin Department of
Commerce. Eligible counties may apply for
a $1,000 grant to establish a local club,
thus enhancing an area's entrepreneurial
culture.
Committee Passes
Health Bills
During an executive session Wednesday, the
Senate Judiciary Committee recommended passage
of three health care bills, by a partisan
vote of 3 to 2.
-
SB-71:
prohibits the recovery of damages from
a person in a wrongful birth or wrongful
life action if the damages resulted
from a condition that existed at the
time of the child’s birth and
the defendant’s negligence contributed
to the mother’s decision not to
undergo an abortion.
-
SB-72:
Prohibits certain organizations or affiliates
that engage in abortion-related activities
from receiving public funds.
-
SB-97:
Eliminates the authority of an adult
family member, a foster parent, a treatment
foster parent, or a parent who does
not have legal custody of an unemancipated
minor to consent to an abortion for
the minor.
Bill to License Midwives Introduced
A bill [AB-709]
introduced by Rep. Gregg Underheim (R-Oshkosh)
would establish requirements for the Department
of Regulation and Licensing (DRL) to grant
licenses to midwives who are not certified
nurse-midwives. Current law recognizes the
practice of nurse-midwifery, but does not
authorize midwifery by non-nurse midwives.
The bill permits licensing of an applicant who has received
a certified professional midwife credential
from the North American Registry of Midwives.
The bill, as drafted, also has the effect
of allowing the practice of midwifery without
any license in that it does not prohibit
unlicensed practice.
In addition, the bill does not require a licensed midwife to
carry medical malpractice insurance coverage
or work in collaboration with a physician
under a written agreement, in contrast to
licensure requirements placed on nurse midwives
under current law.
AB-709 is scheduled for public hearing in the Assembly Health
Committee, Tuesday, Oct. 11 at 10.00 a.m.,
Room 417 North, State Capitol.
Breastfeeding Protection Proposed by Lawmaker
Senator Fred Risser (D-Madison) has
introduced legislation which aims to eliminate
discrimination against breastfeeding mothers.
Senator Risser’s proposal, known as the “Right
to Breastfeed Act”, will allow a mother
to breastfeed her child in any location
where she is otherwise authorized to be.
Currently, thirty other states have laws
which allow mothers to breastfeed in any
public or private location.
For
more information on legislation of interest
to CTCW members, go to the CTCW
Tracking Report. |
| Wisconsin Politics |
 |
| Burke Guilty Plea
Former state Sen. Brian Burke, D-Milwaukee, is
expected to be sentenced to jail time and
incur thousands of dollars in legal obligations
as a result of his guilty pleas Wednesday
in Dane County court. In exchange for the
guilty pleas, prosecutors dismissed 11 felonies
and five misdemeanors.
Burke has agreed to reimburse the state $9,496 for legal fees
paid on his behalf by taxpayers. He also
said he would repay the state for the hours
aides spent campaigning on state time, an
amount that has not yet been determined.
Burke was initially charged with 18 felonies alleging that
he repeatedly broke the law in his race
for attorney general. Dane County Judge
William Foust will determine the sentence
at a hearing at 10 a.m. on Nov. 30.
Sen. Stepp Won’t Run for Reelection/McReynolds Announces
Candidacy
Senator Cathy Stepp (R-Yorkville) announced
Monday that she will not be running for
reelection in 2006. In her first term, Sen.
Stepp was a leading player in many of the
major economic development initiatives that
were passed and signed into law in the 2003-04
legislative session.
Following her announcement, Racine County Executive Bill McReynolds
(R-Racine) stated his intentions for candidacy
in the race for the 21st State Senate seat.
Poll Shows Governor’s Race Close
An online poll showed Tuesday that next
year's governor's race is a statistical
dead heat, with a slight edge going to U.S.
Rep. Mark Green (R-Wis.) over Democratic
incumbent Jim Doyle. Doyle held a slight
edge on a head-to-head basis over Scott
Walker. Both results were within the margin
of error.
Based on 737 Wisconsin respondents with computers who signed
up with Zogby Interactive to participate
in such surveys, pollster John Zogby rated
Doyle's re-election bid as too close to
call. |
| Federal Developments |
 |
| Harriet Miers Next Supreme Court Nominee
President Bush this week chose Harriet.
Miers, a Dallas native, to succeed Justice
Sandra Day O'Connor on the Supreme Court.
Ms. Miers, 60, the first woman to be president of the State
Bar of Texas, is a former Democrat who ultimately
became a leader in the state's Republican
legal establishment. She will join a relatively
small, but prestigious list of justices
without prior judicial experience.
Miers, an alumnus of Southern Methodist University, grew up
in a real estate family in Dallas, served
on its City Council and was the first woman
to become a partner at a major Texas law
firm.
Restaurants Donate to Red Cross
On “Dine for America” day, Oct.
5, restaurants across the country donated
a portion of that day’s proceeds to
the American Red Cross in support of Hurricane
Katrina and Rita relief efforts.
The Dine for America event was created by restaurants and their
employees from across the country united
in the effort to help those affected by
catastrophic national events. Supporting
the Red Cross ensures that the organization
can provide for the needs of disaster victims,
which include emergency food, water and
shelter. |
| In the News |
 |
| Governor
signs new gaming compact with Forest County
Potawatomi: GM Today, Oct. 5, 2005.
Poll:
Doyle and Green in close race for gov:
Daily Cardinal, Oct. 5, 2005.
Georgia-Pacific
to cut 400-plus jobs at Green Bay mill:
Green Bay Press-Gazette, Oct. 5, 2005.
Steel industry
clad in rising costs: Milwaukee Journal
Sentinel, Oct. 5, 2005.
Bush not
set on Fed picks: Milwaukee Journal
Sentinel, Oct. 5, 2005.
Improve
state's business climate (opinion):
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Oct. 5, 2005.
Local
officials renew push for gas tax exemption:
La Crosse Tribune, Oct. 5, 2005.
DNR
leader signs regulatory pact: Appleton
Post-Crescent, Oct. 5, 2005.
SeniorCare's
benefits at risk: Milwaukee Journal
Sentinel, Oct. 5, 2005.
State
should support stem cell research (opinion):
Racine Journal Times, Oct. 4, 2005.
2
utilities buy stake in coal plants:
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Oct. 4, 2005.
MGE,
WPPI buying part of coal plants: Madison
Capital Times, Oct. 4, 2005.
UW
hopes to keep educated workers in state:
Marshfield News Herald, Oct. 4, 2005.
Stepp won't
seek second term in Senate: Milwaukee
Journal Sentinel, Oct. 4, 2005.
Ex-legislator
takes a plea agreement: Milwaukee Journal
Sentinel, Oct. 4, 2005.
Milwaukee
fares well in Midwest job growth: Milwaukee
Journal Sentinel, Sept. 30, 2005.
Sales
tax not pill for relief: Appleton Post-Crescent,
Sept. 29, 2005.
Close
the loopholes in farmland tax law (opinion):
Green Bay Pres-Gazette, Sept. 29, 2005.
Doyle
stands firm on cloning ban veto: Appleton
Post-Crescent, Sept. 29, 2005.
Cloning
ban heads toward expected veto: Milwaukee
Journal Sentinel, Sept. 29, 2005.
Supreme Court
will hear challenges to campaign law:
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Sept. 29, 2005. |
| Upcoming Fundraisers |
 |
| Oct. 10
-
Mark Green (R) gubernatorial candidate, Wisconsin Dells
-
Mark Green (R) gubernatorial candidate, Madison
-
US Rep. Tom Petri (R), Milwaukee
-
Scott Walker (R) Gubernatorial candidate, Milwaukee
-
US Rep. Paul Ryan (R), Racine
-
Rep. Tom Nelson (D-Little Chute), Milwaukee
Oct. 11
Oct. 12
-
Scott Walker (R) gubernatorial candidate, Milwaukee, 5:00
p.m.
-
Rep. Jean Hundertmark (R-Clintonville), Madison
-
Sen. Jon Erpenbach (D-Middleton), Middleton
Oct. 14
Oct. 15
For details, go to Hamilton
Consulting Fundraiser Calendar. |
CTCW Political Tidbits
is a weekly newsletter on Wisconsin political and
policy developments prepared for CTCW members by
The Hamilton Consulting
Group. Employees of CTCW member organizations
can subscribe at: http://www.ctcw.org/form-subscribe-tidbits.html.
To unsubscribe, go to: http://www.ctcw.org/form-unsubscribe-tidbits.html.
© 2005 The Hamilton
Consulting Group |
|
 |
Links
|
 |